Pizza is more than just dough, sauce, and cheese. The toppings are what transform every slice into a unique experience. From rich Italian classics to unexpected flavor combinations, the right ingredients can completely change how a pizza tastes.
At Crosta, we carefully select premium ingredients that bring authentic flavor and perfect balance to every pizza. If you're looking to step beyond the ordinary, here are ten delicious pizza toppings you absolutely need to try.
1. San Marzano Tomatoes
Every great pizza starts with an exceptional sauce, and that's exactly why we use San Marzano tomatoes. Grown in Italy, these tomatoes are naturally sweeter, less acidic, and packed with rich tomato flavor.
Why you'll love it:
- Bright, fresh taste
- Smooth, naturally sweet sauce
- The perfect base for every pizza
2. Bagna Cauda
Featured on our Rossa Pizza, Bagna Cauda is a traditional Italian sauce known for its deep, savory flavor. It adds richness without overpowering the other ingredients.
Perfect for:
- Fans of bold, authentic Italian flavors
- Anyone looking to try something beyond classic tomato sauce
3. Pepperoncino
If you enjoy just a little heat, pepperoncino is a must-try. It delivers a gentle kick that enhances every bite without overwhelming your palate.
Best paired with:
- Tomato-based pizzas
- Rich cheeses
- Savory meats
4. Stracciatella
Soft, creamy, and incredibly luxurious, Stracciatella melts beautifully into every slice. Featured on our Nduja Pizza, it creates a smooth texture that perfectly balances bold flavors.
Why customers love it:
- Creamy finish
- Rich dairy flavor
- Gourmet Italian experience
5. Saba
Not every pizza topping is savory. Saba, a sweet Italian grape reduction, adds subtle sweetness that complements creamy cheese and rich tomato sauce beautifully.
A perfect match for:
- Cream-based pizzas
- Fresh cheeses
- Bold Italian ingredients
6. Honey
One of the biggest food trends today is adding honey to pizza, and for good reason. Our Pepperoni Pizza finishes with a drizzle of honey that creates an unforgettable sweet-and-savory combination.
Why it works:
- Balances salty pepperoni
- Enhances melted cheese
- Adds a smooth finish to every bite
7. Fresh Basil
Fresh basil is simple but essential. Its bright aroma and herbal flavor bring freshness that perfectly complements tomato sauce and mozzarella.
Ideal for:
- Classic cheese pizzas
- Margherita-style flavors
- Light, fresh meals
8. Ricotta Cheese
Featured on our Spinach Pizza, ricotta adds a creamy, delicate texture that's lighter than traditional mozzarella. Every bite feels rich without being heavy.
What makes it special:
- Smooth and creamy
- Mild flavor
- Perfect with vegetables
9. Yellow Tomatoes
Most people have tried red tomatoes, but yellow tomatoes offer a sweeter, less acidic flavor. They add vibrant color and a refreshing twist to gourmet pizzas.
You'll enjoy them if you like:
- Fresh vegetable toppings
- Balanced sweetness
- Unique flavor combinations
10. Bacon Jam
Our Potato Pizza features rich, savory bacon jam, creating a comforting blend of smoky, sweet, and caramelized flavors. Combined with crème fraîche and leeks, it's one of our most unique pizzas.
Why customers order it again:
- Sweet and smoky flavor
- Rich, hearty texture
- Comfort food with a gourmet twist
Bonus: Don't Forget the Dip
Want to elevate your pizza even more? Add our Ranch Dip for an extra layer of creamy flavor that pairs perfectly with every crust.
Which Topping Will You Try First?
Whether you're a fan of classic Italian flavors or adventurous gourmet combinations, there's always something new to discover at Crosta.
From the sweetness of San Marzano tomatoes and honey to the creaminess of stracciatella and ricotta, every ingredient is chosen to create pizzas that are fresh, balanced, and unforgettable.
Visit us today and discover why our handcrafted pizzas have become customer favorites, one delicious topping at a time.